Why "no cigar"?

English as a Second Language English Teacher Explanations (ESL Tests)
1

English Language Tests, Intermediate level

ESL/EFL Test #283 [color=blue]“English Slang Idioms (5)”, question 2

I obviously still don’t understand the concepts we’ve been discussing in class. Every time I answer the teacher’s questions, she says “Close, but no ….”

(a) cigar
(b) coupon
(c) prize
(d) purpose

English Language Tests, Intermediate level

ESL/EFL Test #283 [color=blue]“English Slang Idioms (5)”, answer 2

I obviously still don’t understand the concepts we’ve been discussing in class. Every time I answer the teacher’s questions, she says “Close, but no cigar.”

Correct answer: (a) cigar

Your answer was: [color=red]incorrect
I obviously still don’t understand the concepts we’ve been discussing in class. Every time I answer the teacher’s questions, she says “Close, but no prize.”
[size=200]_________________________[/size]

Why “no cigar”, please?

2

It is an idiom.

—Idiom
2. no cigar, Informal. not being a winning or successful effort, as if not good enough to earn a cigar as a prize: He made a good try at fielding the ball, but no cigar.

The idiom originates in the former use of cigars as prizes at fair competitions.

3

Hi Mr Micawber,

Thank you for your explanation. I think maybe I’ll use this idiom sometimes.

Best regards,

Yuri

4

Good! I use it a lot.

5

I’ve been working my arse off all year and still couldn’t get this test right. it’s obvious I’m not goin to get any cigar.