Hi there - I’ve been curious about the difference in meaning (if any) of using “was” instead of “has been” in a sentence.
For example:
“The lion has been let out of his cage”
or
“The lion was let out of his cage”
Is there any difference in meaning? Is there a proper time to use one versus the other?
Thank you.
In your context either one can be used.
Yes, there is.
-
The present perfect is used when the time period has NOT finished: I have seen three movies this week.
(This week has not finished yet.)
The simple past is used when the time period HAS finished: I saw three movies last week.
-
The present perfect is often used when giving recent news: Martin has crashed his car again.
(This is new information.)
The simple past is used when giving older information: Martin crashed his car last year.
(This is old information.)
-
The present perfect is used when the time is not specific: I have seen that movie already.
(We don’t know when.)
The simple past is used when the time is clear: I saw that movie on Thursday.
(We know exactly when.)
-
The present perfect is used with for and since, when the actions have not finished yet: I have lived in Victoria for five years.
(I still live in Victoria.)
The simple past is used with for and since, when the actions have already finished: I lived in Victoria for five years.
(I don’t live in Victoria now.)
Thank you very much. Good explanation.