Dear teachers,
In my class, my teacher wrote on the blackboard:
Much as we may pride ourselves on our good taste,
we are no longer free to choose the things we want. (1)
So, she continued to write:
…of our good taste, we are no longer free to choose the things we want.
a. So proud may we be
b. Although we may pride ourselves a great deal
c. Proud as we may be
d. Pride ourselves as we may
My teacher chose Proud as we may be .
1/Coul you tell me why a,b,d aren’t not correct? a,b,d are all correct in grammar?
2/In (1), why “as much”, but not “much as”?
Best regards
Tung Quoc
PS: In my class, my teacher doesn’t explain, she only gave the final answers.
Alan
August 16, 2006, 7:31am
2
Hi,
You asked:
Much as we may pride ourselves on our good taste,
we are no longer free to choose the things we want. (1)
So, she continued to write:
…of our good taste, we are no longer free to choose the things we want.
a. So proud may we be
b. Although we may pride ourselves ourselves a great deal
c. Proud as we may be
d. Pride ourselves as we may
My teacher chose Proud as we may be.
1/Could you tell me why a,b,d aren’t not correct? a,b,d are all correct in grammar?
2/In (1), why “as much”, but not “much as”?
My first comment is that grammar and meaning are different aspects. In other words what you write/say has to make sense.
is unfinished. You need to rewrite: We may be so proud that …
again is unfinished. You could say: Although we may pride ourselves on being accurate/on our accuracy …
is also unfinished since it lacks ‘on’
Your last point: isn’t that what your teacher in fact wrote?
Alan
Dear teacher,
Yes, all were written by my teacher. She took them in Developping skills by L.G. Alexander .
"
is also unfinished since it lacks ‘on’ "
1/I understood that a,b,d weren’t chosen because they’re unfinished , as you explained.
Could you rewrite all sentence with Pride ourselves as we may on…
2/ Proud as we may be of our good taste, we are no longer free to choose the things we want. (*) (The final answer that my teacher chose)
(*) is correct?
Many thanks for your response
Tung Quoc
Yankee
August 16, 2006, 11:59am
4
is also unfinished since it lacks ‘on’ "
1/I understood that a,b,d weren’t chosen because they’re unfinished , as you explained.
Could you rewrite all sentence with Pride ourselves as we may on…
2/ Proud as we may be of our good taste, we are no longer free to choose the things we want. (*) (The final answer that my teacher chose)
(*) is correct?
Hi Quoc
1/
Pride ourselves as we may on our good taste, we are no longer free to choose the things we want.
(The word on replaces the word of )
2/
Yes, your teacher’s solution is correct.
Amy