Good, so why are you sad

English as a Second Language English Vocabulary, Grammar and Idioms
1

:blossom: In the Name of God, the Compassionate, the Merciful. :blossom:

Hi!

A: Why are you sad? What happened at the doctor’s?
B: I didn’t go to see doctors. I went to see one doctor.
A: I know. At the doctor’s means at the doctor’s office, at the office of the doctor, just one doctor.
B: OK. I went to the doctor’s.
A: Good, so why are you sad. ←
B: Oh.
A: Oh, don’t cry. Why are you crying? Well, tell me what happened at the doctor’s. How did it go?
B: It didn’t go well. It went very badly.

Good, so why are you sad.

1- What is “Good” short for?

2- Do we need a question mark here?

Thank you

2 Likes
2

Hi! Great questions — let’s break them down:

1. What is “Good” short for in “Good, so why are you sad”?

“Good” here isn’t really short for anything — it’s being used as a discourse marker. It usually means something like:

  • “Alright,”
  • “Okay,”
  • “That’s settled,”
  • “We’ve got that clarified.”

In this case, A is acknowledging that B finally said the sentence correctly (“I went to the doctor’s”), so “Good” means something like:

“Okay, now that we’ve fixed that, let’s move on.”

It’s not grammatically short for another word or phrase, but it carries the meaning of satisfaction or moving forward in the conversation.

2. Do we need a question mark in “Good, so why are you sad”?

:white_check_mark: Yes, we do.

“Why are you sad” is clearly a direct question, and it should always end with a question mark.

So the sentence should be:

Good, so why are you sad?

Even though it starts with “Good,” which sounds like a statement, the main clause is a question.

3 Likes
3

Thank you so much, Torsten :rose:
Very nice.

In addition to the equivalents you mentioned, could “That’s good” be a correct synonym?

2 Likes
4

Yes
(I was tempted to just say “That’s good”, but decided that would be too confusing.)

3 Likes
5

Thank you so much, Arinker :rose:
Very nice.

6

I agree, Arinker. There are certain things in life that confuse us. I sometimes have that too. :heart:

7

Yes, “That’s good” can sometimes be used in a similar way, but there’s a slight difference in tone and formality:

Comparison:

“Good, so why are you sad?”
– Very casual and quick. It moves the conversation along.
– Common in spoken English.

“That’s good. So why are you sad?”
– Slightly more formal or complete.
– Feels like a full thought: you’re explicitly acknowledging something positive before asking the next question.

In your dialogue:

If A had said:

That’s good. So why are you sad?

—it would still make sense, just a bit more structured and polite.
But since A is reacting quickly and casually, just saying:

Good, so why are you sad?

feels more natural in that flow of speech.

So yes — “That’s good” can work, but it’s not always interchangeable in tone and rhythm. Want to see a few natural examples?

2 Likes
8

Thank you so much, Torsten :rose:
Very nice.
Sure, why not?

1 Like