My question is, if you use “saw” then don’t you need to use “happened”
My guess is HAPPEN isn’t a verb. It’s an infinitive? Because you can’t say SAW HAPPENED?
What’s the grammar rule on this? SAW is a special verb but you need an object to use the infinitive of “to happen”.
Hi Monday,
As you know we can say: I saw IT happen/happening last night.
But in the sentence: What I saw happen … , What=the thing(s) that… .Therefore,we can omit the object “IT”.
What I saw happen=The thing that I saw happen.
Compare what and that:
What happened was my fault.(=The thing that happened was my fault.)
Hope that helps!
Morteza
Thanks
But let me dig in a little deeper
In this sentence, “what i saw happen was”
Which word is the subject and which is the direct object?
I saw it happen = “I” is the subject and “it” is the direct object
but when you add “what” in the sentence, it seems like “what” becomes the subject of the sentence, and “I” becomes the direct object?
What part of speech is the word “HAPPEN”
I just can’t seem to fiqure it out
If it’s an infinitive, then what is the direct object? I don’t think you can omit that?
Hi,
“What I saw happen last night” is a noun clause and is considered as a subject.
(What=The thing that) is an object- (I) is a subject-…
Regards,
Morteza
We use the base form of the verb in these expressions. I saw it happen. What I saw happen was… Also, to see/hear someone do something: I saw him approach the door. I heard him ring the bell. Etc. (This form of the infinitive without “to” is called by various names. I’m American and to me this is the “base form”. Others call it the “bare infinitive.”) Base form verbs are also used in causative expressions with make/let/have (someone do something) and with modals (can/should/must/will do, etc.)
Isn’t this a simple case of relative tense vs absolute tense? Absolute tense is relative to NOW. Relative tense is relative to some other time other than now.
“What I saw” places the viewer in THAT time. So the tenses are relative to that time.
What I saw happen [ at that time ] was…
What I saw happening [ at that time ] was…
What I saw had happened [ at that time ] was…
What I saw about to happen [ at that time ] was…
These are different tenses relative to that time - NOT relative to now.
You’re right! The viewer is making a statement now about what happened at a particular time in the past. I would avoid using words like ‘absolute’ and ‘relative’, because they might make things difficult to understand. Therefore, I think, it would be better if you said: ‘not connected to the present, but to that time and stated in the present’.