We have plenty of expressions like this, but I can’t come up with one that sounds similar to your guesses. Maybe it involved some creative play on words.
I thought, like Jamie, that there would be many sayings of the form ‘packed like… in…’, but Ms Google offers up 99% sardines, and nothing much else imaginative; certainly nothing that sounds like ‘quails in a squawk’ or ‘quills in a hawk’ or whatever.
.
This got me curious and sent me on a hunt for some more imagery. The comparisons I found are useless to Tom, but I thought they were fun:
(The place was packed/full as/like)
turkeys on their way to an Adopt A Turkey sanctuary farm in upstate New York
a fish taco
a calzone
a Brazilian bikini
a supermarket before a hurricane
a mosh pit
a rich man’s fridge
a woman’s suitcase
vultures on a corpse
sushi
frozen food and battery hens
tuna in brine
a truck-stop diner at dawn.
herrings in a barrel
a cattle car
like sardines in a crushed tin box (I liked this version of the popular one)This one uses (most of) the proverbial phrases at once:
Like a can of sardines in a Tokyo subway car in Times Square at midnight on New Year’s Eve.Like this forum on the evening of March 26th(That last one is the only one I made up!) :roll:
Eureka! I first thought it could be ‘like wheat in a sock’. But there’s a definition of ‘shock’ that fits perfectly: a pile of sheaves of grain stacked upright in a field for drying.
I wasn’t even courteous enough to tell you that I finally found the said expression. By the way, did you see it then? Do you find it reasonable enough?
. Packed like wheat in a shock is a good simile, though a bit dated-- I doubt many people know what a shock of wheat is. But I had completely forgotten this thread.
.