- He has (a) good knowledge of English grammar.
- Please take (a) good care of him.
- Is your car giving (a) good mileage?
- Do you get (a) good mileage from your car?
In all these sentences ‘a’ is optional or compulsory?
Please comment.
Thanks.
The “a” is not correct in any sentence except for #1, in which it is optional, though I would lean towards including it.
Hello, Luschen:
Thanks to your reply, I have learned a new thing, i.e.:
-
The phrase lean to/towards take an -ing form of the verb, doesn’t it?
-
Can the phrase lean to/towards be synonymous with the phrases in bold below and can I use the following phrases in place of it?
a) ... though I would [b] be prone to include[/b] it.
b) ... I would [b]be inclined to include[/b] it.
Many thanks..
Luschen, I have seen my American friends always use ‘toward’ not 'towards. You are an exception now.
I did some research concerning the first sentence and came to the conclusion that “a” is obligatory in this case.
Thanks for your reply, Foreigner.
Hello, DEAR TEACHER:
When I wrote the phrase thanks to I meant “owing to, due to”. Am I wrong?
Thanks.
No Foreigner, you weren’t wrong in your choice of preposition, but your punctuation was not right and so the meaning became confused:
Thanks to your reply I have learned something new.
Thanks for your reply. I have learned something new.

No Foreigner, you weren’t wrong in your choice of preposition, but your punctuation was not right and so the meaning became confused:
Thanks to your reply I have learned something new.
Thanks for your reply. I have learned something new.
So the comma in the first sentence is not needed. Thanks.)

Anglophile:
Thanks for your reply, Foreigner.
When I wrote the phrase thanks to I meant “owing to, due to”.
On the other hand, if you meant as I took it, a semi colon would be more suitable than a comma, I think. Thanks for your reply; I have learned something new.
What do you say?
I say a full stop or a comma would be better.
A semi-colon rather than either of those serves no purpose there.