Dear teachers,
I write (a) or (b) or both are correct?
a. If there is a fire, ring this bell.
b. If there is fire, ring this bell.
If both are correct, what is the diference btw them?
Quoc
Dear teachers,
I write (a) or (b) or both are correct?
a. If there is a fire, ring this bell.
b. If there is fire, ring this bell.
If both are correct, what is the diference btw them?
Quoc
IMHO, fire is the flames, light and heat that are produced when smth burns and flames that destroy houses and so on :a fire burning of wood and etc for cooking or heating.
Hi Pamela,
Thanks a lot but please answer on my concret question.
Thanks
Quoc
In your sentence I’d use fire because ring the bell assumes an alarm.
.
I think it’s sometimes a question of “typical” collocation, Quoc:
If there is a fire, ring this bell. (This is what someone might actually say to you.)
In case of fire, ring bell. (This is something you might see on a sign next to some sort of fire alarm bell)
There is a fire in the kitchen/livingroom/bedroom/stairwell.
There was a fire on Main Street yesterday.
There was a fire in the field, so we called the fire department.
We lit a fire.
This material withstands fire better than that material.
The house is on fire.
Where there’s smoke, there’s fire.
The boss is under fire because sales have fallen 50% (figurative)
Using an article with the noun fire usually refers to a particular thing/area that is or was burning. Without an article, it’s either a more general concept or idiomatic.
Amy
Dear teacher,
If I write:
If there is fire, ring this bell. (a)
(a) is correct in grammar and have the meaning?
Quoc
Quoc, I think I’ve already explained things in quite a bit of detail.
Now, it’s your turn to put on your thinkng cap:
Do you still think that “If there is a fire…” might be the same as “If there is fire…”?
Dear teacher,
“Fire” in: If there is fire (1) is as in:
Have you insured your house against fire?
“Fire” in (1) refers to a general concept.
“Fire” in: If there is a fire (1) is as in:
It was a fire in the warehouse.
You wrote:
Why did you mention the bell? “The bell” is unrelated here.
So I think:
If there is fire, ring the bell is correct.
How about your opinion?
Quoc
Hi Quoc
If there is a specific bell designed specifically for use when something in/near the bell’s location is burning, then I’d say “There is a fire”. Basically I’d look at that as a specific event.
Amy
Dear teacher,
Please read:
The man will take my place if I am absent.
has the same meaning with:
The man will take my place in case of my absence.
So,
How do you change the sentence:
In case of fire, ring the bell. (1)
by using “If there is…”
In this case, you say:
If there is a fire or if there is fire…?
If you say “if there is a fire” (2)is correct, how do you explain the difference btw “fire” in (1) and “a fire” in (2)?
Quoc
Can I deviate a bit from the topic, please?
I think same is the case with [color=red]noise!
1- There was a strange noise in the room.(some particular situation)
2- I hate noise. (general)
Tom