simple/progressive

English as a Second Language English Vocabulary, Grammar and Idioms
1

Which of the two sentences is correct?

(1) My Dad has promised to have a barbeque for ages.
(2) My Dad has been promising to have a barbeque for ages.

   Thanks.
2

I think only number two is correct. It is interesting that “My Dad has promised to have a barbecue for the ages.” is also correct, but has a slightly different meaning.

3

I would say that both are acceptable but the continuous form does strengthen the idea that this promise has been around for a long time, which is suggested by the expression ‘for ages’.